Frequently Asked Questions

Other Civil Disputes

What evidence is needed for judicial review?

Judicial review applications are focused on the lawfulness of the decision-making process, so the evidence needed is generally the record of what the decision-maker had before them and how they reached their decision — rather than new factual evidence about the underlying matter.

The decision-maker's record

The record of proceedings — which typically includes the decision itself, written reasons, any materials filed with the tribunal, and a transcript or notes of the hearing — is the primary evidence on a judicial review. Courts are generally limited to reviewing what was before the decision-maker, so gathering that record promptly and completely is important.

Evidence about procedural fairness

Where the challenge is based on procedural unfairness — for example, that you were not given adequate notice, not allowed to respond to adverse information, or that the decision-maker had a conflict of interest — evidence about what happened during the process, such as correspondence, notices, and hearing records, will be relevant.

When new evidence may be relevant

In limited circumstances, evidence that was not before the decision-maker may be admissible — for example, to demonstrate a reasonable apprehension of bias or to establish jurisdiction. Whether to seek to introduce new evidence and how to do so is a question best addressed with legal advice early in the process.

This is general information about administrative law in British Columbia, not legal advice. For guidance on your situation, contact Northpoint Legal.